Tony® Award

• Musical Performance (1949) - Winner
• Best Actor in a Musical (1949) - Winner
• Choreographer (1975) - Nominee
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Supporting Actress (Musical) (1975) - Nominee
• Best Choreography (1975) - Nominee
• Costume Designer (1975) - Nominee
• Best Featured Actress in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Actor (Musical) (1975) - Nominee
• Best Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Supporting Actor (Musical) (1975) - Nominee
• Best Costume Design (1975) - Nominee

Theatre World Award

• Best Debut Performance (1949) - Winner
• Best Debut Performance (1949) - Winner
• Best Debut Performance (1975) - Winner

Best Actor in a Musical

• Tony Award - (1949) - Nominee

Drama Desk Award

• Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actress in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actress in a Muscial (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Choreography (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Choreography (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actor in a Musical (1975) - Nominee